In Hot Pursuit Of The Recanting Victim
In case you didnt know, we are living in a state where uncooperative victims of domestic violence are ducking and running from prosecutors and investigators who wish to compel their testimony. At this very moment, thousands of victims are holed up in their homes or are on the lam in their attempts to avoid contact with law enforcement officials.I have many concerns about the governments aggressive practice of pursuing uncooperative victims and I believe there needs to be a change in the way our criminal justice system handles first time offenses involving domestic violence.
The Recanting Victim
The recanting victim phenomenon is nothing new. Any professional who has ever worked with domestic violence cases knows that a great number of people who report domestic violence frequently change their mind about pressing charges, once things have cooled off and reality sets in about the consequences of a criminal conviction. It is often the case that the accused and accuser make up, move back in with one another, and attempt to make things better.
Out of concern for people inflicted with the Domestic Violence Syndrome (i.e., people who are perpetually trapped in abusive relationships), prosecutors have adopted the philosophy that it is their job to rescue victims from making the wrong decision, and that it is their ethical duty to bring the perpetrator to justice, in spite of the consequences a conviction will have on the parties relationship or family.
The Use of Spontaneous Statements
Using an exception to the hearsay rule, often called the excited utterance doctrine, prosecutors used to successfully prosecute domestic violence cases, when the victim either refused to testify or recanted his or her statement. During trial, the prosecutor would simply play the 911 tapes taken from the incident and call the responding officer to the stand who would testify as to what the victim told him about the incident during the investigation. This type of evidence was permitted under the theory that the victims spontaneous statements were reliable since they were made when the victim was under a great deal of stress from the incident, and therefore the victim was not likely to have fabricated his or her story.
Prosecutors knew that it was much easier to secure a conviction when the victim refused to cooperate, given the impossibility for the defense to cross examine a 911 tape or a police officer who is merely regurgitating what the victim had said during the investigation. Thus, the preferred domestic violence case for most prosecutors was one in which the victim refused to cooperate and never set foot in the court room.
The Crawford Decision
In 2003, the glorious days of prosecuting domestic violence cases came to a screeching halt based on a United States Supreme Court decision entitled, Crawford v. Washington. According to the Crawford decision, the Confrontation Clause excludes "testimonial" hearsay from trial unless the declarant testifies at trial, or the declarant is unavailable to do so and the accused had an opportunity to cross-examine the declarant at the time of the hearsay. The high courts decision put an end to the long standing practice of calling police officers to the stand to testify on behalf of the recanting victim. Consequently, it is now necessary in most cases that the victim testifies in order for the prosecution to obtain a conviction.
The New Game
In spite of the Crawford decision, the District Attorneys Offices mad dog approach to these cases has not changed. Prosecutors are now going to extreme lengths to compel victims testimony. For example, when victims refuse to appear in court, prosecutors sometimes obtain body attachments or warrants for their arrests, and then send their investigators after the victims to have them hauled into court. In other instances, prosecutors will go so far as to charge victims with contempt of court for failing to appear. Thus, it is not unheard of these days where both the accuser and the accused are facing criminal charges.
Furthermore, frightening cat and mouse games are being played out on the streets as a result of the District Attorneys current position of chasing after victims. Government officials are pounding on the doors of victims homes, going to victims work places, and conducting around the clock surveillances of the victims known hangouts. Meanwhile, victims are taking time off of work, refusing to answer their phones, and booking trips out of the state to avoid detection.
At the risk of being labeled a proponent of domestic violence, I believe it is time for a change in the way our system handles cases involving uncooperative and recanting victims of domestic violence. My belief that we need to change the criminal justice systems method for handling these cases is based on the following four arguments:
1) The governments position of not listening to victims of domestic violence when they do not wish prosecution is based on a flawed assumption that these people cannot think for themselves. Most people who call the police because of a domestic disturbance do not suffer from Domestic Violence Syndrome. After all, women are much more independent than they were in the past, and it is much easier for people to leave relationships these days with the help of emergency protective orders issued by the police and restraining orders issued by the family courts.
2) If a person truly wants to continue in a relationship or has hopes of keeping a family together, why is the government so quick to interfere with that decision? Isnt it a no-brainer that a criminal conviction for domestic violence is likely to damage the relationship, especially where there has been a loss of liberty or employment opportunities?
3) If our main concern in these cases is to protect victims of domestic violence, why are we making it scary for people to call the police? Certainly in some cases it is appropriate for the police to simply keep the peace without making an arrest. However, with the current policy, people who are deserving of this basic police service do not call the police because of the severe consequences that usually follow.
4) Why is our government wasting so much money chasing after recanting victims when the likelihood of obtaining a conviction is so little? Although I do not have statistics to support this argument, I know from being in court that there is an enormous increase in the amount of these cases dismissed in spite of the governments expenditures in attempting to locate uncooperative or recanting victims.
A New Approach- Domestic Violence Diversion Programs
In a state that has shown drug addicts a great deal of compassion by decriminalizing the use and possession of drugs and by creating diversion programs, I believe we should be more sympathetic to uncooperative victims and their families who wish to stay together. People who call the police regarding domestic disturbances should be listened to when they desire prosecution and also when they do not.
Admittedly, in some cases it may not be appropriate to follow the victims request. Some examples are where there are repeat offenses or where there are serious injuries. In these cases the government should prosecute the offender in spite of the victims wishes, to promote safety and to send a strong message to the public that domestic violence is wrong.
Conversely, where it is a first offense with little or no injuries, and the victim expressly states that he or she does not wish prosecution, the system should give the offender the opportunity to participate in a domestic violence diversion program. This program would require the offender to attend batterers treatment classes, and upon successful completion of the program, the case would be dismissed. Without a doubt, this program is much more likely to achieve the desired results of teaching people how to manage their anger and resolve conflicts, while allowing people to keep their relationships intact.
Copyright 2006 Law Offices of Donald P. Schweitzer
Donald P. SchweitzerEuphoria Cologne
Silver Chandelier Earrings
Car Truck Trader
Dancing Gemmy Hamster
Dictionary Of Symbols
Thousand Oak Retirement Planning Services
Cyprus Chaise Lounger
Flower Online Silk Wedding
007 Box Set
Construction Laboror Jobs
Christmas During Holiday In Its Kid New York
Keen Hiking Boot
Dance Dance Revolution Arcade
Sky Sports Football
Kaunas Lithuania Vacation
Radio Control Hobbies
Baby Infant
Patio Chaise
Water Ice Crystal
100 100 America America Best Best Place Place Retire Retire
Contractor Diego General In Licensed San
Gardening Gardening Orthos Orthos Shade
Diego Go Go House Tree
1 B Vitamin
2007 Football Schedule
05 Football
Citifinancial Ca
Ice Tea Jar
New Born Baby Name
Postales Animadas
Bike Cheap Dirt Helmet
Being Guide Longevity Pilates Pilates Power Power Stefanie Through Well
100 Mtv Rock Top Video
1 1 1 2bshack 417 Radio Top
Cookie Decorate Holiday
Play It As It Lays
1950s Lamp
Credit Loan
Band Exercising
Dishnetwork Satellite
Cell Family Phone Plan Verizon Wireless
Symptons Of A Heart Attack
Swanson Supplements Vitamins
Family Travel Magazine
0 Car Deal Finance
West Palm Beach Schools
Marriott Hotel Fort Lauderdale Florida
Home Loan Home Loan Refinance Mortgage Refinancing
Bag Mesh Strap Tote
History Of Pilates
Dance Dance Music Revolution
Discount Sports Supplements
Beaches
Clubbing
0 Apr Credit Cards
Ca Cucamonga Garden Rancho Victoria
University Of Michigan Hockey Jersey
10 Ben Cartoon Network
Cross Bow Exercise Machine
Beach Event Long Mary Queen
Famous Celebrity Birthday
Pets Vets
Cafe
Free Celebrity Email Address
1 Army Bird Dog O Royal Thai
Carb Chocolate Low Recipe
10 10 Golf Handicap In Lower Under Week
Employment Work From Home Jobs
Crisis Strategies
06 Beach Bike Daytona Week
Construction Management Form
Crystal Mastodon Skull
Bed Used Wall
Colleges In Atlanta Georgia
04 Advice Dating
1 800 Bedding Mattress
Learn To Sail Chesapeake Bay
Brown Paper Grocery Bag
Middle Resource School Science Teacher
Aerobic Exercise At Home
Furniture Kitchen Office
Driving Direction Travel Map Of Mexico
Country Treasures
Golden Ratio In Art
06 Block Party
Toy Tractor Implement
Band Gold Wedding White Womans
Work From Home Data Entry Position
Katy Texas Phone Book
Oklahoma State Flower Mistletoe
Carpet Wholesale American
Little Girl Earring
10 Fact Global Warming
World Internet Tv
Cosmetic Surgeon Miami
Effects Of Global Warming In Antarctica
Weird Al Mp3s
Direct Install Satellite System Tv
Easy And Healthy Dessert
Adult Costume Halloween Homemade
Rolls Paper
007 Movies
Boot Burton Hail Snowboard
Daytona Beach Events
Bake Turkey Time
100 Bernardino California Hike In Mountain San Southern Trail
100 America Best Place Retire
Scorpio Rising
Dessert Kid
Vegetarian Meat Substitute
1 Acb
Number 6 Fuel Oil
Shawnee State
Asp Cart Code Shopping
Dogwood Pictures
Hoover Buccaneers Official Football Site
Beach Holiday Summer
Home
Bike Honda Motorcycle Sports
Australia Basket Gift Melbourne
Camera Night Video Vision
W18
World Time Clock
Perculator Coffee Pot
Pet Fish Screensaver
Elbow Stretch Tennis
Folic Acid Hair Loss
10x Lamp Projector Sharp Xr
1 5 Adjustable Mortgage Rate
Ticket Win
1 6 Black From Growth Hair Longer Now Ultra Year
10 Britney Charlie Chocolate Factory
Construction Course Golf Miniature
16 Info Mesothelioma
Placebo Mp3
Canadian Shoe Wholesales
Television
Sql Install
Beach Dorchester Hotel Miami
P4
Banking Making Money Money Saving Simple Steps Teen Tip
Basketball College Rating Rpi
Fishing
Wearing Flower In Your Hair Wedding
Customer Relationship Management Best Practice
Playstation Xbox
Microsoft Notepad
Australian Finance Direct
Male Celebrity Picture
Club Fc Soccer Texas
0870 Numbers
Hard Rock Cafe Gatlinburg
2006 2007 Card Hockey
Exercise Picture Woman
Forecast Forex Recommendation Strategy Trading
10 Anxiety Anxiety Coping Fear Relieve Simple Ways Worry
Global Marketing And The Environment
Accessories Marine
Clint Eastwood Video
Teenagers Clothing
06 Field Hockey
Web Site For Medical Technology
Cheapest Flight To Cyprus
100 Airline Ticket Under
06 Dodge Charger
Forsyth Inn Park Savannah
360 Accessory Xbox Cooling X
Glasses
02 Nokia
Make Karaoke Music
Law Office Houston
Christmas Decorating Front Yard
1 6 Black From Growth Hair Longer Now Ultra Year
Comcast Internet Promotion
Madison Square Garden Seating
Breakfast Movie Tiffanys
Television And Electronics Repai
Pets
Time Share Rental And Grand Cayman
Reptile Pets
Truck
Pennsylvania Newspaper Obituary
Basketball Purdue Purdue Womens
100 Bird Got Name Their They
1 Cup Coffee Makers
Wedding Reception Illinois
Driving Job Opportunity Truck
0 Car Deposit Finance Uk
Prague Holidays
Steve Brown Constructions
Anxiety Disorder Generalized Medication Used
Travel Agent Career Info
Wholesale Garden Supply
Led Tail
Baby Com R Toy Us
Wholesale
Hepatic Abscess
Finance A Car No Credit Check
Kaunas Lithuania Vacation
Wild Bird Song
Flaming Bible
Christmas Simpsons Village Village
Apartment Finder Pet Small
Apartment Finder In Atlanta
New Hampshire Condominium
Box Business In Vending
100 Top
Chicago Newspaper Obituary Sun Times
Alaska Fishing Fly In Trip
10 Gauge Shotgun
Contractor Louis Painting St
2008 Corolla
Mary Larocca Glen Cove New York Obituary 2007
Playstation Xbox
Post Office In San Jose
Table Top Rear Projection Televisions
1000 Christmas Decoration Feast Gift Hint Idea Tip Tradition
Baby Baby Gift Newborn
Nokia Phoenix
1 Acre
1840 1865 Fur Missouri Trade Upper
Italian Pasta Recipe Sausage
Hogan School Of Real Estate Tucson
Make Money Business Opportunity Online
Apartment Fenced Pet Search Yard
Vintage Baby T Shirt
Amazon Chaise Lounge
Northwest Airline Flight Status
Health Care Research
Apartment Knoxville
Disney Karaoke Princess
Health Insurance Life Online Quote
Cooder Graw
Shopping Mall Boston
Highway Driving Condition
Bad Bank Credit Loan One
Criminal Law Book
Application Benefit Green Health Tea
1 Cartoon Political War World
Sarasota Florida Vacation Rental
What Can Be Done To Stop Global Warming
Disney Invitations
2007 Dress Prom White
10 In Lesson Living Organic Simple
Ashtanga Yoga Primary Series
1 Dvd Minute Workout
P10
Injury Attorneys Florida
Phone Test Equipment
Diesel Shoe
Exchange Kuala Lumpur Online Stock
Flight London Sydney
Bryan Adams Mtv Unplugged
12 Barbie Castle Dance Dancing Magical Princess
Cat Dancing
Coach Discounted Wallet
Cheese Store Wine
Office Product Star
Football Player Ranking
Book Book Cook Cook Dessert Library Living Southern
Austin Hotel Reservation
12 Cafe Cyber Step
Antivirus Gold Removal
Comerica Web Banking
Michigan Personal Injury Lawyer Attorney
Logo Water Bottle
Utrecht Art
Washington Ia Real Estate
Standard Process Vitamins
Bad Credit Home Loan Mortgage People
1 5 Adjustable Gym In Little Tikes
100 Tea Tree Oil
0800 Dial Free Internet Up
Benedictine Military School
Christmas Piano Music
Air Cheap Ticket Toronto
Fiberglass Race Car Part
Dance
10 Christmas Dress
Karaoke Wedding Song
Baby Baby Care Care Infant Skin
Massage
Bed Luxury Pet
Boys Klub
1 Acre Of Land
Baseball Game Sports
Theatrical Costume
Drowning In Love Sea
Cabazon Outlet Shopping
Cheap Flight London Australia
Homepage Hijacked
As Gift Order Wine
05 Dodge Magnum
Shaving Pubic Hair
Wicker Cat Bed
0 Advance Card Cash Credit
Ipod 15 Gb
Drinking Glasses Stainless Steel
001 001 Cholesterol Diet Keyword Miva R
Concerning Gift Spiritual
Shopping Outlet Lancaster Pennsylvania
Miami Vacation Package
Customized Driving Directions
Mesothelioma Lawyer California
Pay As U Go Phone
Coat Of Arms Symbols
A Framework For Customer Relationship Management
Pilot Games
Drift Net Fishing
L20
Democrat For 2008 Presidential
Family Kid Pool Water Wet
Bw3 Coupon Free Meal Restaurant
Opra Winfry
Death Rat
Costume Indian Jewelry Wholesale
Bag Burton Cruzer Golf
Duster Spray
Affiliate Directory Health Product Program Site
Cafe Del Mar 2
Olympus Digital Camera Sale
Bus Mta Planner Trip
Chocolate Ice Cream Recipe
Yacht Charter In Florida
Sports Site
Career Center Inc Planning
Search By
Yacht
19th Century Chaise Lounge
New York Drug Rehab
Mineral Right Oil
Make Fireworks
Happy Holidays You Bastard
Sun Glasses Hut Watch Station
07 Gmc Truck
Coffee Gourmet Rock Round Service
Accessory Ipod Mini Photo Pour Video
Airfare Airline Cheap Cheap Dirt Discounted Flight Fly Greece Thessaloniki Ticket Ticket Travel
Auction Automobile Car Used
Jacuzzi Whirlpool Spa
Hurricanes Global Warming No Evidence
Florists Calgary Alberta
Oklahoma Benign Mesotheloma Asbestos
3 Cafe Dollar Restaurant
Canadian Emigration
Austin Denise Pilates Video Workout Yoga
Improving Gas Mileage
Extrasensory Peerception
Exchange Jewelry Manhattan
24 Hrs Fitness
Cheapest Flight To London
1 Coffee Cup Maker
American Staffordshire Terriers
Carved Hiking Staff
Travel
Sba Loan Loan Small Business Administration
Right Brain Exercises
Baby Infant
Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely
Timber Wolf
Power Rangers Dino Thunder Costume
Music Transfer From Ipod To Ipod
Youth Dance Class
32 Plasma Televisions
Travel By Air Cheap
3 Bed Orlando Villa
1 2 Book Culinary Life Susur
1 800
Contractor Electric Rochester
Bar Club Karaoke
Baseball Diamond Clipart
Tops Baseball Card
Chesapeake Chaise
2 Book Discover Dvd Pilates Set Yoga
0 Car Deposit Finance Uk
110 Car Complete Driving Emergency Guide Road Safe Staying Survive Them
Career Fashion
2 9642 9642 9642 Cosmetic Cosmetic Dermatology Dermatology Dvd Hair In In Laser Light Procedure Procedure Rejuvenation Removal Resurfacing Series Skin Textbook Volume
570 Radio Sports Xtra
Deep Sea Fishing Freeport Tx
Virginia Real Estate Listing
0 Car Deal Finance New
Cheapest Price
1 2 1
Cat Deterrent
Kitchen Plan
1 5 Adjustable Mortgage Rate
Christina Millian Pics
Com Doll Pocket Pocket Polly Toy
Book Travel Used
Fishing In Port Aransas
Orphanage Haiti
Ca Diego Diego San San Sea World
Baby Fireplace Gate
Restaurant Albuquerque New Mexico
Grocery Store Thumb Tom
Camp Football High Picture School
06 Fire House In
Powderfinger Lyrics
0 Apr Business Card Credit Online Services
Energy Experts
Medium Psychic Psychic Reading
Hair Dye Removal
Colorado Home Mortgage Rate
Free Cheer Music And Dance
Asbestos Mesathelioma Lawyer Illinois
Cooking Halloween Project
A Inside Basketball Hoop
0 Fitness Life T3
0 Degree Sleeping Bag
Island Colony Waikiki
2008 Malibu
Stocks
Australia Lonely Pictorial Planet
Landscape And Irrigation Magazine
Clear Skin Acne Treatment Proactiv
1 6 Book Law Plato X
Office 2003 Professional Oem
Sirius Satellite Antenna
Beautiful Dating Woman
Vitamin And Amino Acid Supplement
1 Gb
Volkswagon Auto Parts
07 2 Fifa Play Soccer Station
1 800 Bedding Mattress
Information Medical Specialist
Bird Feeder Food
Money Cash
10 Honeymoon Top Vacation
Help Debt Counseling
Dirt Bikes For Sale By Owner
Automotive Filter Oil
Marin County Realtors
Make Money In Forex Market
Eve In New Party Toronto Years
Footsteps For Jesus Domain Name Search
Fairtax Book
Fitness Her Magazine
20 Christmas Lamp Leg Story
Indian Restaurant Coupon
Free Michigan Health Insurance Quote
320 Camera Digital Hp
Hiking
General Contractor Web Site
Contractor Equipment Wilmington
Pet Supply Wholesale And Manufacturer
Relax And Alert Herbal Equine Supplement
Hiking Hawaii
Bio Engineering
Hotel Maria Villa
Persecuted Christians
Myspace Editor Code
Adac Verkehr
00 221 Lund Se Sweden
0190 Dialer
Vending
2 Gift Girl Old Year
11595 Bradley Construction Florida Ft Kelly Myers Road
Towel Dispensers
Holiday Inn Express Career
10 In Las Restaurant Top Vegas
Belly Clip Dancing Egyptian Video
Call Conference Cost Low
1 E Magazine Zines
Breakfast Club Actor
Singapore Singaporesingapore Tourism
Brise Marine
Wholesale
Canada Car Cheap Insurance
Gift
Airline Delta Flight Info
Tea Tree Oil Acne
Construction
Kentucky State Flower
Katy State Texas United
0603 Resistor
007 Starr
1 File
Aau Antonio Basketball San
Alberghi Taormina
1 Dan
Broadcasting Job
Floppy Drive Cable
1 Birthday
Boat Insurance Salvage
Red Mangrove
Carol Christmas Production Script
Acne Acne Microdermabrasion Scar Treatment
0 Financing Car
12 Step
Is Olive Oil Good For Hair
Fayette County Health Department
Diabetic Chocolate Chip Cookie
Power Sarah Yoga
Presenters Sky Sports
Free Recording Studio Software Download
Xbox Moded System X
Club Fairfield In Table Tennis Usa
Rimless Reading Glasses
Ski Vacation Rental
W35
Bulletin Church Clipart Free Religious
1 Episode Garden Meteor
Stage Of The Water Cycle
Christmas Ornament Western
Agent Estate Illinois Real
1 Cream Ice Team Volume
Baby Mexican Name
Party Entertainment Southern California
02 Pay As You Go
Beer Glasses Stella
Evidence For Global Warming
Free Line Dance Video
Glasses
1 Week Detox Diet Plan
Bank Business E Icici
Culinary Institute Orlando
San Francisco Office Space Leasing
Basra Airport
Bobby Abreu
Forex Betting
Office
Cartoon Network Star War
Magazine
E70 Fitness Horizon
Private Health Insurance In Australia
Celebrity Index Oops Pokies
Cheap Flight To Sydney Australia
Magazine Circulation
1st Apple Tour Vacation Vacation
Automotive Car
Alternative Treatment For Depression
Adoption In Arizona
Car Kalispell Law Lemon
Comparison Internet Marketing Strategy
Fha Va Home Loan
Career Step Medical Transcription
Internet Cafe Japan
06 Beach Bike Myrtle Week
Guinness Long Rugby Shirt Sleeve
Comfort Inn International Drive Orlando
006 Airline Flight Singapore
The Perfume Spot Coupon
1 Thessalonians
0190 Dialer
Long Valley Brew Pub
Newborn Halloween Costumes
Advertising Internet Marketing Media New Video
Tennessee Malignant Symptoms Of Mesotheloma Litigation
Wisconsin Dells Bed And Breakfast
12 Cafe Cyber Step
Internet Shopping Directory
Noeud Marin
Guide New Restaurant York
Tea Party Game For Child
posted by eileen88897 @ 6:12 PM
0 comments
